Sheriff Seth Langston is head over heels for local wild child Jessie McAllen and has been for years. The trouble is, she has eyes only for Seth's rodeo star brother, Chase. Even though he considers Jessie his girl, Chase is an incorrigible ladies' man with a wandering eye and no chance of settling down soon.

Jessie is ready to move away from Cattle Creek to put her feelings for Chase behind her, but after she shares a white-hot kiss with Seth, things get a little complicated. Jessie realizes that her heart should have been his all along - and, in the face of sudden tragedy, they'll discover if their newfound passion will tear the Langston men apart or make the family stronger than ever.